Ha. Taking my potential set-up! I'm also looking at the Bullys and Nittos. Great minds think alike!
Had Nitto Terra Grapplers on my previous Tacoma and Wrangler before that. I personally wouldn't think twice about getting them again. Great tire. Can't compare noise level of them but I didn't find them "loud". Before the Nittos on my Tacoma I had the Continental TerrainContact A/T. Couldn't get them to balance, changed them out for the Nittos and never looked back.
Side note: remember that overall diameter is one thing but the wheel offset is another area that could cause rubbing.